No Penalties For Not Reporting Interest Earned On Tax Refunds

In a legal dispute concerning a senior citizen and the income tax authorities, the Mumbai tax tribunal's bench has declared that the penalty imposed for not reporting the interest earned on the elderly citizen's tax return is not justified. 

The ITAT bench emphasized in their judgment that the interest portion of the refund should not be evaluated until it is actually received.

Hence, not disclosing information on the income tax return should not be considered as a case of "underreporting" income. Section 270A of the Internal Revenue Code imposes significant penalties on taxpayers who are negligent in situations involving both underreported and misreported income.

In this specific case, the taxpayer, K Singh, filed her income tax return for the fiscal year 2016–17, reporting a taxable income of nearly Rs 1.9 crore. When her tax return was selected for review, her income was estimated to be approximately Rs 2 crore. The interest she earned on her income tax refund, which she had not initially reported, covered the shortfall of Rs 9.7 lakh.

According to Section 244A of the Income Tax Act, the tax department is obligated to pay 0.5% interest on the refund amount every month or portion of a month. This interest is considered taxable income categorized under the "income from other sources" section.

The income tax officer sent a notice to impose a penalty on Singh under Section 270A. The taxpayer argued that she had willingly disclosed the interest from her income tax refund during the scrutiny assessment, long before receiving the notice. 

Therefore, it should not be considered as "underreporting" income. Additionally, when she filed her income tax return, she hadn't received a refund through a check or electronic transfer, and there was no indication that she would receive one.

She appealed to the ITAT (Income Tax Appellate Tribunal), which ruled in her favor. This decision came after the lower tax authorities had initially rejected her appeals.

Also Read: Are Rs. 1000 Notes Returning Back to Circulation

Leave a reply